Where to Try Key Lime Pie on The Beaches of Fort Myers & Sanibel


The official state pie of Florida is celebrated here as much or more than anywhere in the Sunshine State. Chefs across our islands take pride in serving scratch-crafted variations of this light, creamy dessert. So, in honor of National Pie Day, here are a few of our island restaurants happy to serve you a slice of Florida’s sweetest delicacy.


Key Lime Bistro:  This colorful Captiva Island spot lives up to its name by serving award-winning slices of key lime pie daily. Made-from-scratch dishes and a laid-back setting make this a relaxing place to enjoy breakfast, lunch or dinner.

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille:  With locations on Fort Myers Beach, Sanibel and Captiva, Doc Ford’s is a must-dine for any visitor. Sip a cocktail and savor the flavors of traditional island fare, then top it off with a slice of homemade key lime heaven.

Mucky Duck:  Enjoy casual beach dining in an English pub setting, backlit every evening by a magical Florida Gulf sunset. Their seafood is locally sourced and freshly served, and their key lime pie is key to this sweet experience.

Bubble Room:  Famous tastes and endless décor greet you at this one-of-a-kind Captiva favorite. Stop in for an authentic slice of key lime pie made with graham cracker crust and topped with kiwi, strawberries and homemade whipped cream.

McGregor Cafe:  This cozy Fort Myers café is a cherished lunch and breakfast choice for locals and visitors alike. Stop for a scrumptious slice of key lime pie on their low-key, shaded patio.

We Think You'll Also Like

Continue Exploring